Is Peyton Manning Top 5 All Time?

Let the arguments begin!  My buddies and I have already started.  One of them must have been high when he said Peyton Manning is one of the top 5 players of all time!  I don't think you can look at just the stats.  Sure he has the most wins, touchdowns, yardage, MVPs and on and on.  My gage is is total domination as a player.

Here are my top 5 of all time.  Go ahead and take your best shot at my picks.

1. Jim Brown

2. Lawrence Taylor

3. Barry Sanders

4. Jerry Rice

5. Bo Jackson